You’re overwhelmed with deadlines, your day has been chaotic, and your brain is spinning. Then, almost instinctively, you reach for ice cream, pizza, or a bag of chips—foods that seem to soothe your nerves and give you a moment of relief. But why? Why does stress drive us to crave comfort foods, often high in sugar, fat, or salt?
The answer lies in evolutionary mismatch—a conflict between instincts that evolved to help our ancestors survive and the realities of our modern environment. What once served as a survival mechanism now works against us, pushing us toward choices that don’t align with our long-term well-being.
For our ancestors, stress was a life-or-death response to immediate threats: a predator attack, injury, or a food shortage. When faced with stress, the body released hormones like cortisol and adrenaline, which prepared them to fight or flee. At the same time, stress signaled the need to replenish energy stores to endure the threat or recover afterward.
Mismatch Today: Modern stress—work deadlines, financial worries, or relationship conflicts—is rarely resolved by physical activity or immediate action.
In the ancient world, food wasn’t always readily available. When it was, our ancestors instinctively sought out calorie-dense foods like fatty meats, fruits, and nuts to store energy for future periods of scarcity. These high-calorie foods were rare and highly rewarding, thanks to the brain’s release of dopamine, the "feel-good" chemical.
Mismatch Today: Comfort foods like chips, cookies, and fast food are engineered to mimic these high-calorie, rewarding foods.
During stress, cortisol levels rise, which can increase appetite and specifically drive cravings for high-fat, high-sugar foods. This is because these foods activate the brain's reward system, counteracting the unpleasant effects of stress and temporarily restoring emotional balance.
Food isn’t just about physical nourishment—it also plays a role in emotional regulation. In ancestral communities, eating was often a social activity that reinforced bonds and reduced stress through connection and shared experience.
In times of uncertainty, humans instinctively seek out familiar and predictable experiences that provide a sense of stability and safety. For many people, comfort foods are tied to memories of warmth, care, and security—perhaps a childhood meal or a treat shared with loved ones.
Stress activates the amygdala, the part of the brain responsible for emotional responses, while reducing activity in the prefrontal cortex, which governs rational decision-making. This shift makes you more likely to act on cravings and less likely to consider long-term consequences.
In the past, stress often involved physical threats that required movement—running, fighting, or enduring harsh conditions. Physical activity helped regulate stress hormones like cortisol and adrenaline, while food replenished the energy burned during the response.
Craving comfort food during stress isn’t a sign of weakness—it’s a deeply ingrained survival mechanism rooted in our evolutionary past. By understanding the evolutionary mismatch at play and implementing strategies to align your choices with your modern needs, you can navigate stress in ways that support both your emotional and physical well-being.
Subscribe to Mind the Gap! – my weekly newsletter.